cwfs/src/CwF/Structures.lagda.md

open import Cat.Prelude
open import CwF.Base

module CwF.Structures where

This file defines several additional structures a CwF might have, such as pi types, universes, sigma types, and identity types. (currently only pi types)

First are pi types, because a type theory without them are pretty uninteresting.

record has-Pi {o h f : _} {𝓒 : Precategory o h}
              (cwf : is-CwF {o} {h} {f} 𝓒) : Type (lsuc (o ⊔ h ⊔ f)) where
  open Precategory 𝓒
  open is-CwF cwf
  field

The type formation rule for pi types is straight forward.

    ∏ : {Γ : Ob} (A : ∣ Ty Γ ∣) (B : ∣ Ty (Γ ; A) ∣) → ∣ Ty Γ ∣

Likewise, the introduction rule is what one would expect.

    Cλ : {Γ : Ob} (A : ∣ Ty Γ ∣) (B : ∣ Ty (Γ ; A) ∣) (b : ∣ Tr (Γ ; A) B ∣)
       → ∣ Tr Γ (∏ A B) ∣

Application also needs to be introduced.

    app : {Γ : Ob} {A : ∣ Ty Γ ∣} {B : ∣ Ty (Γ ; A) ∣} (f : ∣ Tr Γ (∏ A B) ∣)
          (x : ∣ Tr Γ A ∣) → ∣ Tr Γ (B ⟦ ⟨id, x ⟩ ⟧ ) ∣

Substitution must also be closed under all of these.

    ∏-subst : {Δ Γ : Ob} (γ : Hom Δ Γ) (A : ∣ Ty Γ ∣) (B : ∣ Ty (Γ ; A) ∣)
            → ∏ A B ⟦ γ ⟧ 
            ≡ ∏ (A ⟦ γ ⟧) (B ⟦ ⟨ γ ∘∘ p , q ⟩ ⟧)

    Cλ-subst : {Δ Γ : Ob} (γ : Hom Δ Γ) (A : ∣ Ty Γ ∣) (B : ∣ Ty (Γ ; A) ∣) 
               (b : ∣ Tr (Γ ; A) B ∣)
             → PathP (λ i → ∣ Tr Δ (∏-subst γ A B i) ∣)
                     (Cλ A B b [ γ ])
                     (Cλ (A ⟦ γ ⟧) (B ⟦ ⟨ γ ∘∘ p , q ⟩ ⟧) (b [ ⟨ γ ∘∘ p , q ⟩ ]))

There's quite a hefty pathp here...
typeof app (transport (λ i → ∣ Tr Δ (∏-subst γ A B i) ∣) (f [ γ ])) (x [ γ ])
B ⟦ ⟨ γ ∘ p , q ⟩ ⟧ ⟦ ⟨ id, x [ γ ] ⟩ ⟧
B ⟦ ⟨ γ ∘ p , q ⟩ ∘ ⟨id, x [ γ ] ⟩ ⟧
B ⟦ ⟨ γ ∘ p ∘ ⟨id, x [ γ ] ⟩, q [ ⟨id, x [ γ ] ⟩ ] ⟩ ⟧
B ⟦ ⟨ γ ∘ id, x [ γ ] ⟩ ⟧
B ⟦ ⟨ id ∘ γ , x [ γ ] ⟩ ⟧
B ⟦ ⟨ id, x ⟩ ⟧ ⟦ γ ⟧
typeof app f x [ γ ]

Welcome to intensionality hell.

  app-subst-pathp : {Δ Γ : Ob} (γ : Hom Δ Γ) {A : ∣ Ty Γ ∣} {B : ∣ Ty (Γ ; A) ∣} 
                      (f : ∣ Tr Γ (∏ A B) ∣) (x : ∣ Tr Γ A ∣) 
                  → B ⟦ ⟨ γ ∘∘ p , q ⟩ ⟧ ⟦ ⟨id, x [ γ ] ⟩ ⟧
                  ≡ B ⟦ ⟨id, x ⟩ ⟧ ⟦ γ ⟧
  app-subst-pathp {Δ} {Γ} γ {A} {B} f x =
    B ⟦ ⟨ γ ∘∘ p , q ⟩ ⟧ ⟦ ⟨id, x [ γ ] ⟩ ⟧
      ≡˘⟨ ⟦⟧-compose ⟨ γ ∘∘ p , q ⟩ ⟨id, x [ γ ] ⟩ B ⟩
    B ⟦ ⟨ γ ∘∘ p , q ⟩ ∘ ⟨id, x [ γ ] ⟩ ⟧
      ≡⟨⟩
    B ⟦ ⟨ γ ∘ p , transport (λ i → ⟦⟧-tr-comp γ p A (~ i)) q ⟩ ∘ ⟨id, x [ γ ] ⟩ ⟧
      ≡⟨ (λ i → B ⟦ ⟨⟩-∘  ⟨id, x [ γ ] ⟩ (γ ∘ p) A (transport (λ i → ⟦⟧-tr-comp γ (p {Δ} {A ⟦ γ ⟧}) A (~ i)) q) i ⟧) ⟩
    B ⟦ ⟨ (γ ∘ p) ∘ ⟨id, x [ γ ] ⟩ , transport (λ i →  ⟦⟧-tr-comp (γ ∘ p) ⟨id, x [ γ ] ⟩ A (~ i))
                                               (transport (λ j → ⟦⟧-tr-comp γ (p {Δ} {A ⟦ γ ⟧}) A (~ j)) q [ ⟨id, x [ γ ] ⟩ ]) ⟩ ⟧
      ≡⟨ ((λ i → B ⟦ ⟨ assoc γ p ⟨id, x [ γ ] ⟩ (~ i) , {!   !} ⟩ ⟧)) ⟩
    B ⟦ ⟨ γ ∘ (p ∘ ⟨id, x [ γ ] ⟩) , transport (λ i →  ⟦⟧-tr-comp γ (p ∘ ⟨id, x [ γ ] ⟩) A (~ i))
                                               (transport (λ j → ⟦⟧-tr-comp p ⟨id, x [ γ ] ⟩ (A ⟦ γ ⟧) (~ j)) (q [ ⟨id, x [ γ ] ⟩ ])) ⟩ ⟧
      ≡⟨⟩
    B ⟦ ⟨ γ ∘∘ p ∘ ⟨id, x [ γ ] ⟩ , transport (λ i → ⟦⟧-tr-comp p ⟨id, x [ γ ] ⟩ (A ⟦ γ ⟧) (~ i)) (q [ ⟨id, x [ γ ] ⟩ ]) ⟩ ⟧
      ≡⟨ (λ i → B ⟦ ⟨ γ ∘∘ p-∘ id (transport (λ i → ⟦⟧-tr-id (A ⟦ γ ⟧) (~ i)) (x [ γ ])) i , {!   !} ⟩ ⟧) ⟩
    B ⟦ ⟨ γ ∘∘ id , transport (λ i → ⟦⟧-tr-id (A ⟦ γ ⟧) (~ i)) (x [ γ ]) ⟩ ⟧
      ≡⟨⟩
    B ⟦ ⟨ γ ∘ id , transport (λ i → ⟦⟧-tr-comp γ id A (~ i)) (transport (λ j → ⟦⟧-tr-id (A ⟦ γ ⟧) (~ j)) (x [ γ ])) ⟩ ⟧
      ≡⟨ {!   !} ⟩
    B ⟦ ⟨ γ ∘ id , transport ((λ j → ⟦⟧-tr-id (A ⟦ γ ⟧) (~ j)) ∙ (λ i → ⟦⟧-tr-comp γ id A (~ i))) (x [ γ ]) ⟩ ⟧
      ≡⟨ {!   !} ⟩
    B ⟦ ⟨ γ , x [ γ ] ⟩ ⟧
      ≡⟨ {!   !} ⟩
    B ⟦ ⟨ id ∘∘ γ , transport (λ i → ∣ Tr Δ (⟦⟧-id A (~ i) ⟦ γ ⟧) ∣) (x [ γ ]) ⟩ ⟧
      ≡⟨ {!   !} ⟩
    B ⟦ ⟨id, x ⟩ ⟧ ⟦ γ ⟧
      ∎


  field
    app-subst : {Δ Γ : Ob} (γ : Hom Δ Γ) {A : ∣ Ty Γ ∣} {B : ∣ Ty (Γ ; A) ∣} 
                (f : ∣ Tr Γ (∏ A B) ∣) (x : ∣ Tr Γ A ∣) 
              → PathP (λ i → ∣ Tr Δ (app-subst-pathp γ f x (~ i)) ∣ )
                      (app f x [ γ ])
                      (app (transport (λ i → ∣ Tr Δ (∏-subst γ A B i) ∣) (f [ γ ])) (x [ γ ]))

Lastly comes the star of the show, \beta reduction.

    Cβ : {Γ : Ob} (A : ∣ Ty Γ ∣) (B : ∣ Ty (Γ ; A) ∣) (b : ∣ Tr (Γ ; A) B ∣)
         (a : ∣ Tr Γ A ∣)
       → app (Cλ A B b) a ≡ b [ ⟨id, a ⟩ ]